The Student News Site of Macalester College

The Mac Weekly

The Student News Site of Macalester College

The Mac Weekly

The Student News Site of Macalester College

The Mac Weekly

FFM seeks feedback on proposal

Fossil Free Mac (FFM), seeking student feedback and support before the board of trustees debates their proposal in May, hosted a town hall on April 1 in the John B. Davis Lecture Hall. The student organization is asking the board to place a moratorium on Macalester’s private partnerships with oil and gas companies.

After classes Monday afternoon, approximately 30 students gathered to watch the presentation, which began with a review of the history of FFM and the changes the organization has undergone.

The group was founded in 2012 seeking full divestment from the Carbon Underground 200 — the top 100 oil and top 100 gas public reserve holders — which Macalester invests in via mutual funds. In 2017, they changed their ask to specifically placing a moratorium on the $40 million Macalester has in private oil and gas partnerships.

Graphic courtesy of Fossil Free Mac.

The board of trustees is currently debating this new proposal. While that conversation has already begun, FFM has yet to receive feedback directly from the board members.

“The board of trustees had their retreat in February and decided not to tell us about what happened at it,” FFM core member Sasha Lewis-Norelle ’21 said. “We did talk with President Brian Rosenberg about this and he gave us the feedback that [the board is] not concerned about the financial argument anymore, they’re more concerned about the efficacy of divestment and whether or not taking only $40 million out of fossil fuels will do anything to the enormous fossil fuel industry.”

FFM responded to this and other board arguments during the town hall.

“Historically, divestment campaigns have worked… the [anti] apartheid movement worked,” FFM core member Emma Harrison ’21 said. “Foundationally, a divestment campaign is about making it unethical to invest in something, that’s the first part of it.”

Harrison added that Macalester should be at the forefront of this ethical movement.

“A moral, ethical institution like Macalester College, which is renowned for its dedication to civic engagement and service to society, should not be endorsing an ethical framework that on the flip side while composting on campus, is invested in fossil fuels,” she said.

The group also responded to the concern that if the college divests from fossil fuels, it will find itself on a “slippery slope.”

“There’s an administration worry that there’s a slippery slope of divestment — that if we divest from fossil fuels, that we would have to divest from everything that anyone finds objectionable and that would overall have a bad effect on the endowment,” FFM core member Hannah Shumway ’19 said.

“Our gut reaction to that is, ‘Would it be so bad to divest from bad things? No,’” Shumway began.

But FFM also disagrees with this argument on a logistical basis. They point to the Macalester College Board of Trustees Guidelines for Investor Responsibility, which the board passed earlier this year. The guidelines set up both a process for groups who want to propose divestment and a system for the board to evaluate these divestment proposals.

“There’s definitely precedent for how these things are handled at this point, so we don’t see some sort of crazy slippery slope happening,” Shumway said. “If there are other students that come with really well-thought-out proposals for divestment, we all think they should all be considered as seriously as our proposal has been considered and the board can make that decision on its merits and not worry about a slippery slope.”

In addition to presenting their organizational goals and responding to board concerns, FFM also discussed the questions they frequently hear from students — including the concern that divestment could negatively impact financial aid at Macalester.

“The financial aid question is probably the thing we hear most often from students and that’s something we’re definitely really concerned about answering,” Shumway continued. “It’s a big question for us, personally. We all receive financial aid at Mac and we want people to know we wouldn’t advocate for something we thought would hurt student financial aid or make Mac less accessible.”

However, based on their research on the endowment, the group is confident that financial aid will be relatively unaffected by divestment.

After the presentation, the core members took further questions from the audience about their experiences with the board of trustees, the economic complexities of their proposal and Macalester investment at large.

Following this gathering, FFM is also pursuing adding a student referendum to the ballot for the spring MCSG elections on April 22. The group will propose the referendum at MCSG’s April 9 meeting and the Legislative Body will vote on that proposal the following week.

Should MCSG approve adding the referendum to the ballot, students will be able to vote either in favor of or against divestment. While the referendum won’t directly approve the proposed moratorium, the vote would act as a representation of student support for divestment, which FFM could share with the board of trustees for their consideration.

Based on their conversations with Rosenberg, FFM believes there’s a chance they’ll be able to attend the board meeting in May to defend their proposal and answer questions. The results of the referendum would be an essential part of that presentation.

“I think the comments and questions we hear from students energize and inform what we say to the board,” Shumway said. “So with this town hall and possible upcoming referendum through MCSG, what we’re really trying to do is show that not only are we passionate about this — those of us who work on it every week — it’s also something that the broader student body cares about and it’s an important issue to people beyond us.”

And while FFM eagerly awaits the board deliberation in May, they say that even a commitment to divestment won’t be the end of the road for their organization.

“We have been pretty strongly assured that we will be their main topic of conversation and we will have an answer by graduation,” Collin Dobie ’19 said. “That’s not to say that if the board does exactly what we want that Fossil Free Mac will drop off the face of the earth next year.

“There are probably always going to be climate justice issues, environmental justice issues, institutions doing things with their money that we’d rather they not do,” he continued. “Fossil Free Mac will continue to hold Macalester accountable to its values.”

View Comments (13)
More to Discover
About the Contributor
Hannah Catlin, Managing Editor
hannah catlin 21 she/her managing editor. Shes an amateur badminton player, a professional ghost hunter, and a master of disguise

Comments (13)

All The Mac Weekly Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • S

    Sonia JamesSep 11, 2019 at 2:43 am

    In accordance with my research, after a property foreclosure home is offered at a sale, it is common to the borrower to still have the remaining unpaid debt on the bank loan. There are many loan providers who try and have all expenses and liens paid by the upcoming buyer. Having said that, depending on particular programs, rules, and state regulations there may be a few loans which are not easily sorted out through the transfer of lending products. Therefore, the duty still lies on the lender that has acquired his or her property in foreclosure. Thank you for sharing your opinions on this weblog.

  • V

    Virginia PayneSep 9, 2019 at 1:38 pm

    Awesome blog! Is your theme custom made or did you download it from somewhere? A design like yours with a few simple tweeks would really make my blog shine. Please let me know where you got your design. Cheers

  • E

    EricAug 30, 2019 at 1:20 pm


    People ask, “why does TalkWithCustomer work so well?”

    It’s simple.

    TalkWithCustomer enables you to connect with a prospective customer at EXACTLY the Perfect Time.

    – NOT one week, two weeks, three weeks after they’ve checked out your website
    – NOT with a form letter style email that looks like it was written by a bot.
    – NOT with a robocall that could come at any time out of the blue.

    TalkWithCustomer connects you to that person within seconds of THEM asking to hear from YOU.

    They kick off the conversation.

    They take that first step.

    They ask to hear from you regarding what you have to offer and how it can make their life better.

    And it happens almost immediately. In real time. While they’re still looking over your website, trying to make up their mind whether you are right for them.

    When you connect with them at that very moment it’s the ultimate in Perfect Timing – as one famous marketer put it, “you’re entering the conversation already going on in their mind.”

    You can’t find a better opportunity than that.

    And you can’t find an easier way to seize that chance than TalkWithCustomer.

    CLICK HERE now to take a free, 14-day test drive and see what a difference “Perfect Timing” can make to your business.


    PS: If you’re wondering whether NOW is the perfect time to try TalkWithCustomer, ask yourself this:
    “Will doing what I’m already doing now produce up to 100X more leads?”
    Because those are the kinds of results we know TalkWithCustomer can deliver.
    It shouldn’t even be a question, especially since it will cost you ZERO to give it a try.
    CLICK HERE to start your free 14-day test drive today.

    If you’d like to unsubscribe click here

  • S

    SteveAug 27, 2019 at 1:20 pm

    Hi There,

    Our company creates custom engaging animated presentation videos for businesses like yours to help increase your online exposures.

    Animated presentation videos help companies explain their products or services more efficiently to potential customers.

    Potential customers engage more when there’s a video presentation, most of us would rather watch a video that explains a product or a service than to read the content of a website to know what the offer is.

    I’m interested in creating an animated presentation video for your company to help increase your online exposure!

    Please reply back to this message and I will send you some of our animated video samples so you can see what I can do to help your business grow this year.

    Thank you,
    Steve S

  • H

    Hassan KhanJul 24, 2019 at 4:55 pm


    Hope you are doing well. I just wanted to know if Ii could send some great article ideas for a guest post on your website.

    If you like the ideas i put forward, i will provide you with high-quality free content/articles. In exchange, all i expect is a back link from within the main body of the article.

    Do let me know if you like this proposal and if i can begin sending you some topic ideas.

    Best Regards

    Hassan Khan

  • L

    Leia DushkinJul 22, 2019 at 5:16 pm

    Mass parsite

  • E

    exuholaMay 12, 2019 at 8:41 pm

    dGhlbWFjd2Vla2x5LmNvbQ## cialis 5 mg cialis for sale pharmacy canadian pharmacy viagra viagra online from my prescription canada pharmacy canadian pharmacy cialis tadalafil generic cialis 20 mg tadalafil generic cialis 20 mg viagra for sale viagra pharmacy pharmacy etimerexu

  • U

    uneabayoxMay 12, 2019 at 8:28 pm

    dGhlbWFjd2Vla2x5LmNvbQ## buy retin a online retin a cream 0.05 torino prov cialis cialis generic levitra package vardenafil 20 accutane accutane online buy propecia online propecia canadian pharmacy online canadian pharmacy price viagra generic cheep viagra cialis 5mg cialis best online buy viagra aselot

  • A

    akujtaMay 12, 2019 at 8:25 pm

    dGhlbWFjd2Vla2x5LmNvbQ## propecia online generic propecia cialis hepatitis c low level cialis use levitra levitra levitra 20mg levitra prednisone online prednisone buy amiroyuxe

  • U

    ufuvgapMay 12, 2019 at 8:22 pm

    dGhlbWFjd2Vla2x5LmNvbQ## viagra viagra buy cialis coupon cialis coupon generic cialis from india generic cialis online generic cialis cialis cialis coupon eduson

  • O

    olnamijuMay 12, 2019 at 8:15 pm

    dGhlbWFjd2Vla2x5LmNvbQ## buy levitra 20mg vardenafil 20mg tablets cialis cheapest price cialis generic generic cialis online cheapest brand cialis prednisone prednisone lowest price viagra 100mg viagra use in women buy lasix buy lasix cialis cialis muestra gratis oedeha

  • S

    Sandra JonesMay 4, 2019 at 8:56 pm


    Apologies for the cold outreach! I thought I would contact you and see if you needed any help with your Instagram growth. We are a small and friendly agency specialized in Instagram Marketing. We can generate an organic following of real, genuine people, who fit your target group.

    We will target followers of popular accounts in your niche. We will engage with the most engaged users by following them and liking their most recent posts on their accounts, and by doing so attracting attention to your account.

    More followers:

    * More exposure for your business, increase sales;
    Reach highly targeted customers for your business who will convert into clients, leads and sales!

    * Larger audience for Infuencers;
    Your posts will reach more people raising the value of your posts.

    * Increase sales and brand awareness;
    Your business, your name, your account will be seen by thousands of people a day. Exposing potential buyers to your brand again and again is part of the consumer journey.

    Our most popular plan starts at 69 USD per month, for which you will get around 1000+ targeted followers each month.

    We have a $1 1 week trial:

    If you have any questions, please let me know. You can contact me at [email protected] or with the chat on the website. I’m looking forward to hearing from you!

    Best regards,
    Sandra Jones
    email: [email protected]