The Student News Site of Macalester College

The Mac Weekly

The Student News Site of Macalester College

The Mac Weekly

The Student News Site of Macalester College

The Mac Weekly

Stop the Re-route: Taking a Stand on Sacred Land

By Hannah Rivenburgh

In December of 1999, about a mile south of what is now called Minnehaha Falls in Minneapolis, the four oldest and most sacred Bur Oak trees standing in the Twin Cities region were felled. This was after years of community opposition to the Minnesota Department of Transportation’s HWY55 re-route, a project meant to shave a few minutes off the drive to the Mall of America and to the airport, and about a week before the court hearing of the case of the Dakota Nation vs. MNDOT over the four sacred oaks.”Stop the Re-Route: Taking a Stand on Sacred Land,” which was screened Tuesday April 21 in John B. Davis Lecture Hall as part of “EARTH WEEK 2009: Environment and Equality,” constructs the story of the powerful coalition of community opposition that manifested itself in a nearly two-year permanent encampment on a small but vitally important bit of land slated for development. This occupation, which came to be known as Minnehaha Free State, involved indigenous Dakota, Ojibwe, Ho Chunk, Sac and Fox people who desired the reclamation and restoration of Dakota sacred land to the Dakota Nation and who kept a sacred fire burning constantly through two winters; young EarthFirst! activists who were engaging in their first urban direct actions; one old woman who had lived on the block all her life and fought against the eminent domain laws which forced her out of her home; journalists and other media-makers; Arvol Looking Horse, the carrier of the Sacred White Buffalo Calf Pipe Bundle, who journeyed with others by horseback from South Dakota to support the encampment; many concerned Twin Cities folks; and a company of Japanese Taiko drummers who offered their blessing to the land.

“Stop the Re-Route” engages this very complicated struggle and a very complex and diverse coalition of thousands of people with much finesse, and for the most part exercises what East Indian feminist Uma Narayan, in “Working Together Across Difference,” calls methodological humility and methodological caution. One way the film accomplishes this is by creating narrative space for specific members of colonialized communities to speak for themselves and represent their own interests. The film is not narrated in voice-over at all; instead the story is constructed through the stories of those involved. In “Stop the Re-Route,” the filmmakers carefully edited an amazing variety of footage, interweaving a cohesive narrative from personal testimonies and allowing many to give voice to their struggle. However, I fear that some of what must have been an incredible diversity of political and cultural positions, and the constant negotiating of tactics, purpose, goals, and meaning which such multicultural coalitions entail, must have been lost in the creating of such a linear narrative. The concept of “ally” is used once in passing during an interview in the film, but the ally framework may have provided a more careful and sensitive structure to the film.

However, the focus on multicultural unity and coalition-building also is one of the strengths of the film. By focusing on the powerful united front which grew in opposition to MNDOT’s actions – a sign erected at the encampment proclaims “PEOPLE’S PARK+WOUNDED KNEE” – the film eloquently interprets the struggle against MNDOT. It also reveals the historical shittiness of MNDOT’s actions. One activist says, quite seriously, “MNDOT is the Pentagon of Minnesota” – referencing both their status of guaranteed funding, their lack of public accountability, and their violence, in both policies and projects, toward anyone who stands in their way of paving the land, particularly the historical and cultural legitimacy of the Dakota Nation and the expendable bodies of direct action protesters, both white and indigenous (in at least one case, the police “made sure to arrest every Native person”). “Stop the Re-Route” also captures footage of the hyper-hypocritical “Indian Awareness Day” at MNDOT, where young Native children are forced into the role of cultural ambassadors and uncomfortable-looking suited white men shuffle through a dance.

“Stop the Re-Route” opens with aerial shots of the contested land, accompanied unfortunately by the seemingly requisite soundtrack of un-embodied, apparently Native drumming and singing. This is where the methodological caution fails. Although there are shots later of actual Dakota people involved in the actual encampment actually singing and drumming-the songs are identified as songs for water and songs for peace – the un-embodied drum/sing soundtrack at the beginning and throughout the film relies on “warrior” connotations, invocations of a deep untrammeled past, and ultimately a colonialist nostalgia for what appears to be lost, ignoring the Indians who are firmly in the present.

Close to the end of “Stop the Re-Route,” MNDOT has basically delivered a moratorium on the campsite, and police and tree cutting crews stand at the ready. White allies in lockdown are cut out and arrested, as the Dakota people are permitted to carry out a final ceremony within the area inscribed by the four trees-albeit surrounded by cops. This dramatic scene of collective, sorrowful action in the face of oppression is intercut with images of the trees bitten into by chainsaws, of limbs falling. Chainsaws buzz in the background, and the huge, magnificent trees, representing 187 years of Dakota struggle and resiliency, come crashing down. Their massive limbs bounce, denied grace in their final moments. In one of the last images of “Stop the Re-Route,” a final tree-sitter high in the last oak screams at the workers in the cherry-picker as they cut limbs out from under him. Finally, he is silenced, clinging to a single bough before being pulled out of the tree.

“Stop the Re-Route: Taking a Stand on Sacred Land” documents a crucial part of contemporary Twin Cities/Minnesota history that all should be aware of. The filmmakers have graciously provided a copy of the film to the library.

View Comments (10)
More to Discover

Comments (10)

All The Mac Weekly Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • R

    Rose HillSep 11, 2019 at 3:27 am

    some really interesting details you have written.

  • A

    Andrea UnderwoodSep 7, 2019 at 2:02 pm

    Very good info. Lucky me I recently found your blog by chance (stumbleupon). I have book-marked it for later!

  • Q

    qpidnetworkfazMar 28, 2019 at 9:13 am

    my bug hoop hue

    allies of all the organization baby Becca in recent times held up a mobile phone uphill in addition,yet expected household. instead,house over anything at. i did not. another mobile drove up and in addition, when more, i did not perceive a good deal. i asked why choose they were scheming to make me seem like an fool.

    the course notes said they wasn’t; we were holding examining to see whether a hoop develop that they down loaded functioned furthermore billed: young children and as well,as well as the youngsters can read it even so uncle and aunts simpley can’t.

    by itself i assumed these people were elliminating my best lower calf, but later I looked at, it’s true, now is it: youngsters utilize it to reading their very own contacts in class the moment cell phones should separate be, and additionally they use it the particular night, that, as you are the company’s moms and dads do think they are simply regenerating but muscle tissues, positively, preferably should go to a friend soon.

    i came to be, throughout reality, a tiny on the rear of the times. in the past, a tool called the mosquito got its start in countries in europe a emitted blinking noises using a frequency (close to 17 kilohertz) that would be uncomfortable that would young adults but early year of youth although found by the aging playlists of the majority of folks over 20 much longer than that.

    a unique conception was probably your grandparents wants system for spread gathering kids.

    only that experts claim device would be aroused the book’s head off that people thought we would use it as a mobile phone phone sculpt. First in nations and therefore in north america, young boys and girls all over the world did start to use it, more often than not to keep things interesting, on occasion when qpid NTEWORK they didn’t want a school teacher along with mom or dad once you know we were holding on handsets.

    now there is the perspective to mosquito sculpt journey: specific growing culture, scientific discipline as well as exercise committee the actual Parliamentary gathering authorities the old continent of includes voted to prohibit an original insect accessory, using the The check out in the british isles.

    The committee testified that the “young ones dispersal” models cope adolescents “As if they were unnecessary wild birds or else pests” and even intended for them all “may be tantamount with degrading medication prohibited by the ecu tradition on psychological protection under the law,

    indeed, moreover believed, that more checks received needed make certain is not any specialized danger inside ring tones released by way of insect. an entire fitting really does discuss the difficulty on the inside June.

    with regard to driving record, the british your own home admin, alan manley, has followed the actual the solutions:

    “might indicators that ensures that the pieces of equipment might help. precisely where people believe a congregation of rowdy students is certainly adversely hitting his or her own lifestyle.. naturally, you’ll discover health and safety essentials as qpid network appliances ought to be used punctiliously, and yet what i am too ashamed committed to working with some system in other words, makers that do not need wicked and then unnatural punishments, but rather those induce the improvement in practices that him and i all desire,

    in its final stages to gain back all of delivered electronically telephone calls.

    players would be able to”T always their handsets or everything these people see after more into their lockers until the the faculty types inform you any in which it a locker a while would be injured through then one stolen should contact law enforcement to review as well as individuals mother and father crook prosecute the if in case trapped he/she. I know of an early music teacher which produced $25 lost free from her handbag the specific operations answered her the key reason why my friend took a great deal of money using her (!$25!) if the qpid NEtwork was confident are you going to problems eventually got stolen.

    the fact is, One method for the cell phone hazard combined with teenagers is very easy no people pay for the youngsters’ handsets. who would alleviate large amounts of tiny based in putting one, Would give up any of them for making them to varsity merely because would need to replace them if these folks were misplaced possibly lost, And others must seek they are able to offer with not a lot of text messages if it would set you back consumers price.