In a summary judgment decision dated Sept. 20, U.S. District Court Judge Patrick J. Schiltz dismissed the remainder of former English professor Kristin Naca’s discrimination and wrongful termination suit against Macalester. However, the more than two-and-a-half year legal battle between the two parties is not over just yet: Naca plans to appeal the decision to the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals.
Naca originally filed her case against Macalester in December 2016, roughly fourteen months after the college fired her for what it claims was an inappropriate relationship with a student.
Naca asserts that the physical relationship commenced only after the student had graduated and thus did not violate any college policy.
Instead, Naca claims that she was fired because of her “systemic Valley Fever, her sincere practice of the religion of Santería, sex, sexual orientation, and her Filipina and Puerto Rican ancestry and national origin.”
She contended that, while she was dismissed, Macalester did not fire straight, white male professors accused of sexual misconduct – identifying sociology professor Terry Boychuk and art and art history professor Stan Sears as two men who kept their jobs despite similar inappropriate behavior.
For several reasons, Schiltz didn’t agree.
Macalester received a number of complaints about Boychuk in the early 2000s, ranging from discomfort with how he discussed the topic of sexual violence in a class to secondhand reports that he had harassed students.
Then, just before he was set to be granted tenure in the spring of 2002, a group of five students sent a letter to then-President Michael McPherson and each member of the board of trustees demanding that he be investigated for sexual harassment.
But none of the letter’s signatories had experienced any harassment themselves, and, after a review process, the board of trustees granted Boychuk tenure and ordered him to undergo sensitivity training.
Schiltz dismissed the notion that Boychuk’s situation was parallel to Naca’s, pointing out both that none of the people who granted Boychuk tenure were involved in terminating Naca and that the conduct Boychuk was accused of is “worlds apart” from what Naca did.
“Simply put,” Schiltz wrote, “the decision of one group of decisionmakers to treat Boychuk favorably – thirteen years before Naca was terminated by a different group of decisionmakers after admitting to much more serious misconduct – does nothing to show that Macalester’s stated basis for Naca’s termination is pretextual.”
Schiltz had similarly little regard for the claim involving Sears, who married a Macalester graduate sometime in the late 1990s several years after she had left the college.
There is no evidence to indicate that Sears and his wife began a sexual relationship during or immediately after her graduation, or that the college ever received a complaint about his conduct.
In fact, throughout his 55-page decision, Schiltz appeared thoroughly unimpressed with Naca’s case – at various points calling arguments of hers “ridiculous,” “much ado about nothing,” “reckless,” and “meritless.”
He had even sharper words for her lead attorney Peter J. Nickitas, whose conduct, he wrote, made it “unusually challenging to determine whether Naca’s version of events is supported by evidence,” and “caused the Court to waste dozens of hours of its time.”
Schiltz later wrote, in denying Naca’s motion to supplement the record after the window to do so had passed, that Nickitas “has a long history of violating the Local Rules of this District, in this case and in others.”
Indeed, Nickitas does have a history of misconduct. He has had his license to practice suspended multiple times in both Minnesota and Wisconsin, most recently in Minnesota for 30 days in 2013 for “harassing and bullying” another attorney.
Despite his previous issues with the court, Nickitas in an interview with The Mac Weekly was contrite in his response to the Court’s criticism.
“Number one, we thank the court for pointing out our areas of disorganization,” he said. “I’m a one-man operation. We take the court’s encouragements for improvement seriously and will try to improve – recognizing that this case has a big record.”
Despite the heavily conservative makeup of the 8th Circuit Court, he feels ready for the appeal.
“I expected a decision in favor of Macalester,” Nickitas said. “And I’ve been preparing ever since oral argument to deal with it.”
Nickitas said he’s confident in his client’s chance to win her appeal, making a point of saying that it “properly belongs to a jury to weigh the facts” of whether Boychuk works as a comparator in the case.
“Due process and protection are not just for accused men,” he argued.
Nickitas would not reveal whether Hlee Vang ’02, who made an accusation of harassment against Boychuk while a student at Macalester and was deposed in this case last year, is still working on Naca’s legal team.
“I speak with her often about the case, and I value her labors in the case,” Nickitas said. “We’ll leave that at that.”
In addition to the discrimination charges, Schiltz also dismissed Naca’s claims of breach of contract and failure to sufficiently accommodate her disability during her final three years at the college.
Of the failure to accommodate charge, Schiltz wrote that Naca’s argument “fail[ed] as a matter of law” – noting that she was granted a number of accommodations, including a lighter laptop and office assistance, and that she admitted herself that she was able to perform the essential duties of her job.
“Naca’s entire claim seems to rest on the mistaken premise that, because she was disabled, she had the right to the precise accommodations that she requested,” Schiltz wrote. “That is plainly not the law.”
“We don’t wish anybody ill,” Macalester President Brian Rosenberg said. “But I think in this case we really felt like it was important that we defend ourselves against accusations of that kind of bias.
“It took a while. But we were pleased with the judge’s decision.”
“We are confident the court’s decision will be upheld, if appealed by Naca,” Sean Somermeyer, one of Macalester’s lead attorneys, wrote in an email to The Mac Weekly. “In fact, given the complete lack of evidence in her favor, in our view an appeal would be frivolous and could result in additional sanctions.”
“We are hopeful that this lengthy matter can now come to an end.”
Naca has until Oct. 21, 30 days after the summary judgment, to file a notice that she intends to appeal. The Mac Weekly will continue to report on this story as it develops.
đèn led âm trần • Sep 9, 2019 at 9:38 pm
Oh my goodness! Awesome article dude! Thank you,
However I am experiencing problems with your RSS.
I don’t know why I am unable to subscribe to it.
Is there anyone else getting the same RSS problems?
Anyone that knows the solution can you kindly
respond? Thanks!!
Dylan Powell • Sep 5, 2019 at 7:37 am
These all YouTube gaming videos are really in good quality, I watched out all these along with my mates.
vanchuyenachau • Aug 27, 2019 at 1:50 am
Free and efficient transportation of North-South freight in Asia, daily departure vehicles – contact 0914.857.068 to receive a good quote, free consultation.
Colin • Aug 12, 2019 at 6:47 pm
Thanks I needed this
khánh chó lừa đảo • Aug 6, 2019 at 6:15 am
khánh chó lừa đảo
khanh cho • Aug 3, 2019 at 1:01 pm
view more
ahivza • Jul 28, 2019 at 12:26 pm
dGhlbWFjd2Vla2x5LmNvbQ## cheep viagra cardiazem with viagra levitra 20 mg vardenafil 20mg tadalafil 20mg tadalafil 20mg viagra online canada viagra viagra viagra cheep viagra viagra cialis.com lowest price tadalafil 20 mg dianboru
oxuhoyok • Jul 28, 2019 at 12:04 pm
dGhlbWFjd2Vla2x5LmNvbQ## viagra online viagra propecia buy propecia 5mg buy viagra viagra levitra vardenafil 20 mg viagra cheap viagra cialis 20mg price at walmart cialis online epiqaih
elefaji • Jul 28, 2019 at 11:40 am
dGhlbWFjd2Vla2x5LmNvbQ## tutuvuci-a.anchor.com [URL=http://mewkid.net/order-cialis/#tutuvuci-u]tutuvuci-u.anchor.com[/URL] http://mewkid.net/order-cialis/#tutuvuci-t http://mewkid.net/order-cialis/#tutuvuci-t http://mewkid.net/order-cialis/#tutuvuci-t http://mewkid.net/order-cialis/#tutuvuci-t http://mewkid.net/order-cialis/#tutuvuci-t http://mewkid.net/order-cialis/#tutuvuci-t http://mewkid.net/order-cialis/#tutuvuci-t http://mewkid.net/order-cialis/#tutuvuci-t exiwiqumu
droh.com • Jul 19, 2019 at 7:48 pm
Excellent blog you have here but I was curious about if you knew
of any user discussion forums that cover the same topics
discussed here? I’d really like to be a
part of group where I can get suggestions from other knowledgeable
individuals that share the same interest. If you have any recommendations, please let me know.
Kudos!
zapatillas nike cortez ni帽o outlet baratas espa帽a online • Jul 18, 2019 at 6:03 pm
nike air max 2015 nr 360 black lime grey running shoes sz 10air jordan 11 womens pink white black topdealsnike jr hypervenomx phelon 3 df tf scarpe da calcetto unisex bambini neropas cher hommes nike air max tn bleu blanc noir website
zapatillas nike cortez ni帽o outlet baratas espa帽a online
nike air max 97 ultra navy blue • Jul 18, 2019 at 6:03 pm
cortez nike mens shoes classic cortez sneaker max ukasics gel lyte iii size? far side of the moonnike air max 90 lunar c3.0 chaussons homme white cool grey black infrarednike air presto fly se uomo scarpe nere team rosse pure platinum 908020 003
nike air max 97 ultra navy blue
nike mens free flyknit nsw green black blue • Jul 18, 2019 at 6:02 pm
nike air max 1 em dame london mahogany bl氓 team bl氓 gr氓 stratanike air jordan 1 retro high cool blue herenoff 67 nike air max 90 womens ice blue black d 8psl34nike air huarache 318429 305 electrolime grises
nike mens free flyknit nsw green black blue
men nike lunarglide4 grenadine shoes gray green australia • Jul 18, 2019 at 6:02 pm
nike air force one basse bordeauxnike air max 90 ultra br triple black sneakernews comnike air max 90 enfant chaussures de course rougenike roshe one premium n艖i cip艖 online rendel茅s
men nike lunarglide4 grenadine shoes gray green australia
nike air force 1 low damskie buty • Jul 18, 2019 at 6:01 pm
wei脽 schwarz schuhe metallisch silber nike kobe a.d. chameleonadidas ultra boost laceless packhot deal 2013 nike lebron x 10 pressure black red dealo0pn nike lebron 15 red black basketball shoe for sale
nike air force 1 low damskie buty
nike air max 90 premium herren schuhe schwarz 700155 402 • Jul 13, 2019 at 3:02 pm
nike air jordan cp3 viii preschoolnike free 5 0 mens white blackbuy nike air force 1 obama style shoescomprar nike rosas 2015 baratas espa帽a outlet online
nike air max 90 premium herren schuhe schwarz 700155 402
nike air max thea beige australia • Jul 13, 2019 at 3:02 pm
wholesale mens nike shox turbo 2 running shoes black fuchsia outletnike free rn flyknit baskets de femmes blanc bleu glow hyper punch noirnike air max prime herren 2017cheap nike air max 95 premium se black metallic gold running shoe outlet
nike air max thea beige australia
black blue shoes royal nike kyrie s1 hybrid • Jul 13, 2019 at 3:02 pm
nike downshifter 7 gs scarpe da trail running bambinanike air max thea premium 2017nike sf air force 1 high rattant锚nis nike air max 90 n煤mero 36 aceito trocas
black blue shoes royal nike kyrie s1 hybrid
cheap nike free trainer 5 0 men black green • Jul 13, 2019 at 3:02 pm
blanc nike air max one pas chercheap air jordan 13 gs altitudenike laufschuh free run flyknit 2018 zapatillas de running para hombrezapatillas nike marron hombre outlet baratas espa帽a online
cheap nike free trainer 5 0 men black green
nike court borough low mujer blanca • Jul 13, 2019 at 3:01 pm
salida moda nike air max 1 mujer es2471 amazonnike vivid pink black white air max 90 trainers sportswearnike air zoom mariah flyknit racer nike chaussure pour homme platine pur blanccheap nike lebron 15 xv black red nba super star basketball shoe for sale
nike court borough low mujer blanca
nike free 50 2 womens purple white • Jun 27, 2019 at 3:37 am
mens nike air max 270 kpu blue navy white blacknike air max 90 national team francenike air force 1 ultraforce mid herren schuhe gr眉n 864014 301popular nike shox turbo hombre blanco todas negro online
nike free 50 2 womens purple white
nike air huarache ultra damskie online • Jun 27, 2019 at 3:37 am
nike herren men s air force 1 mid 07 lv8 shoe gymnastikschuheadatto 2018 nike kd 10 black white scarpe venditanike air max 90 damens schuhe gro脽handel wei脽 tschechischnike tiempo legacy ii fg botas de f煤tbol para para hombre 819218 003
nike air huarache ultra damskie online
nike zoom rival d 10 zapatillas unisex adulto • Jun 27, 2019 at 3:37 am
cheap nike free 30 v2 mens womens shoes white bluenike air force 1 07 premium lx damskiezapatillas nike air max 90 mujer a precios asequibles es38nike air vengeance 429627 6 homme chaussures noir
nike zoom rival d 10 zapatillas unisex adulto
kobe vi for sale 2018 off white nike • Jun 27, 2019 at 3:36 am
nike air jordan fly 23 spiderman schoenenzapatillas nike mercurial vapor xii academy neymar mgchaussures baskets nike air max 90 cuir marron pas cherzapatilla de mujer nike negro blanco wmns air max motion lw
kobe vi for sale 2018 off white nike
nike nike air max 90 prm em hombre marino azul p煤rpura plata online • Jun 23, 2019 at 8:38 pm
nike womens free run 2 black white running shoefeminino nike air max 2016 sapatilhas rosa jade comprarnike zoom kobe 1 prelude prelude 1nike air max 87 green pink royal blue black white
nike nike air max 90 prm em hombre marino azul p煤rpura plata online
hombre nike negras azul verde air max flyknit leather zapatillas • Jun 23, 2019 at 8:38 pm
nike air max 90 essential herren sneaker wei脽 schwarznike air max tn 2016 black royal blue white mens shoesnike air max light essential mystic greennike air presto men black white viii shoes
hombre nike negras azul verde air max flyknit leather zapatillas
nike stefan janoski max l prm chaussures de skate homme • Jun 23, 2019 at 8:38 pm
adidas nmd xr1 primeknit core blacknike wmns air force 1 07 prm scarpe da ginnastica donnanike jr tiempox legend vi tf chaussures de foot mixte b茅b茅nike benassi solarsoft homme chaussures 917551 701
nike stefan janoski max l prm chaussures de skate homme
latest hot sale nike sb dunk high prem tricolor women shoes blue red white • Jun 23, 2019 at 8:38 pm
neuesten nike air max 90 damen laufschuhe wei脽 blau rosa shopschuhe nike kyrie 4 black gold preis auf anfragechaussures baskets nike air max tn requin pas cher pas chernike hypervenom phantom iii ea fg volt jaune
latest hot sale nike sb dunk high prem tricolor women shoes blue red white
nike kobe 9 em gs black black court purple tour yellow • Jun 23, 2019 at 8:37 pm
nike damen air max 1 ultra moire blau blau wei脽 704995 401nike air max 95 sneakerboot kakilegit air jordan 6 low infrarednike air max 90 ultra essential rouge
nike kobe 9 em gs black black court purple tour yellow
nike air speed turf gs womens shoes gray black white • Jun 23, 2019 at 8:37 pm
nike basket air max bw ultra noir grosses soldes v5390r7pgd8kj酶pe nike air max 1 jewel hvit r酶d trainersbuy sell nike free v40 all white nike free run 50 women flyknit air maxscarpe sportive nike air max flair 50 m
nike air speed turf gs womens shoes gray black white
nike blazer high premium atari pack • Jun 23, 2019 at 8:37 pm
unisexs shox el 11 best nike running shoes nike code au594 black silver2016 nike mercurial victory v tf turf fotballsko r酶d s酶lv svart for damechaussures baskets chaussures basket nike pour femme pas chernike damen flex raid laufschuhe
nike blazer high premium atari pack
2016 nike mercurial victory xi fg firm ground chaussure de foot bleu rouge blanc • Jun 23, 2019 at 8:37 pm
vente basket nike femme pas chereinkaufen nike fu脽ball schuhe tiempo ligera iv ic herren wei脽 schwarz goldnike free 5 flyknit femme bleu vert offres du nouvel ancheap nike air max thea print women sale
2016 nike mercurial victory xi fg firm ground chaussure de foot bleu rouge blanc
nike air max 95 femme minuit brouillard noir rose feuille • Jun 23, 2019 at 8:37 pm
zapatillas nike force 1 outlet baratas espa帽a onlinenike jr mercurial victry 6 df agpro 32 euhot 2015 nike air jordan 1 i retro todos negronike air max 2015 white black grey mens running shoes
nike air max 95 femme minuit brouillard noir rose feuille
adidas hulton spzl and archive shoe • Jun 23, 2019 at 8:36 pm
outlet mens nike air max tn shoes silver grey whitegrandelection nike air max thea femme chaussures pas cher almens nike free mercurial superfly sp black 667978_001 reviewsnike schuhe damen schwarz air max
adidas hulton spzl and archive shoe
317813 112 nike dunk low women white white lemon • Apr 20, 2019 at 3:32 am
air max 90 ultra essential sneakerherr skor svart explorer 2 s golfskor blackwhiteanthracite nikeus 38 nike air jordan 11 high retro shoes men sneakers www superfsk combuy nike air vapormax utility black grey kixify marketplace
317813 112 nike dunk low women white white lemon [url=http://www.deviselectricitegratuit.com/2019_release/317813-112-nike-dunk-low-women-white-white-lemon]317813 112 nike dunk low women white white lemon[/url]
adidas adidasm20922 superstar da uomo anni 80 bordeaux m20922 uomo • Apr 20, 2019 at 3:32 am
nike air jordan true flight cream grade school girls shoewomens nike roshe one hi sneakerboots gray orangenike kyrie 4 standing rockblack nike free rn men s running shoe lgadqiu
adidas adidasm20922 superstar da uomo anni 80 bordeaux m20922 uomo [url=http://www.newsoomaali.com/turnschuhe/adidas-adidasm20922-superstar-da-uomo-anni-80-bordeaux-m20922-uomo]adidas adidasm20922 superstar da uomo anni 80 bordeaux m20922 uomo[/url]
buty nike air max 90 se leather gs 859560 001 • Apr 20, 2019 at 3:32 am
nike blazer low studio available now2018 nike kd 10 all star 897817 400 basketball shoes for men 3 2018 off white nikenike air vapormax kpu 2018 womens grey pink on salenike free 5.0 mens white cool grey anthracite summit white
buty nike air max 90 se leather gs 859560 001 [url=http://www.smartcreditrating.com/remise/buty-nike-air-max-90-se-leather-gs-859560-001]buty nike air max 90 se leather gs 859560 001[/url]
burgundy and white jordans • Apr 20, 2019 at 3:32 am
nike air max thea jcrd trainers for women burgundy light rednike sb blazer mid vintage navy red gum july 2011urban united kingdom women nike internationalist 94324944air force 1 03907 lv8 quotjust do itquot
burgundy and white jordans [url=http://www.wtnweather.com/cheap/burgundy-and-white-jordans]burgundy and white jordans[/url]
nike n7 fashions an air max 2016 • Apr 20, 2019 at 3:32 am
adidas marincheap nike air max 1 green light green white mens shoes online outletadidas adiprene hitop 1990smens sneakers nike air max 90 em dark blue blue nike shoes nike
nike n7 fashions an air max 2016 [url=http://www.christinefkelley.com/offer/nike-n7-fashions-an-air-max-2016]nike n7 fashions an air max 2016[/url]
nike free tr fit 4 womens training shoes perfect pink white laser crimson • Apr 20, 2019 at 3:32 am
adidas superstar ii negro cream pagina oficial onlineadidas rapidarun knit scarpe nero o7508nike wmns classic cortez se prm dam skor rea pv7136nike air max 97 zapatillas de deporte para hombre
nike free tr fit 4 womens training shoes perfect pink white laser crimson [url=http://www.pulsemarketingbangor.com/blog/nike-free-tr-fit-4-womens-training-shoes-perfect-pink-white-laser-crimson]nike free tr fit 4 womens training shoes perfect pink white laser crimson[/url]
kris bryant wears three different colors adidas dipped cleats • Apr 20, 2019 at 3:32 am
shop womens blue adidas originals superstar 2 print casual shoes salethe nike air force 1 high retro qs game royal is now availableair jordan 13 low quai 54 white blue nike air max 90 nike shoesnike cortez basic sl gs forrest gump white varsity red blue 807471 103 size 10
kris bryant wears three different colors adidas dipped cleats [url=http://www.realhoustonhousewife.com/club/kris-bryant-wears-three-different-colors-adidas-dipped-cleats]kris bryant wears three different colors adidas dipped cleats[/url]
nike tee shirt crest fc barcelone football bleu gar on • Apr 20, 2019 at 3:32 am
stilvoll nike sweatjacke im college stil grau meliert damennike air force 1 07 lv8 independence day 823511 601acheter air max 95 pas cher taille 36 pas chernike dunk clear m忙nd
nike tee shirt crest fc barcelone football bleu gar on [url=http://www.gwelupfruitsandmore.com/vente/nike-tee-shirt-crest-fc-barcelone-football-bleu-gar-on]nike tee shirt crest fc barcelone football bleu gar on[/url]
adidasadiosboost21 adidasadiosboost21 • Apr 20, 2019 at 3:31 am
nike sb paul rodriguez 7 hyperfuse maxadidas jeremy scott 2 0 wingswomens nike hypervenom cleatswomens nike free run 2 purple white black
adidasadiosboost21 adidasadiosboost21 [url=http://www.dellaise.com/en-mens-sale/adidasadiosboost21-adidasadiosboost21]adidasadiosboost21 adidasadiosboost21[/url]